As the new Istanbul II communique suggests, Somalia and Somaliland accepted a joint solution of almost all the agendas and substance that were raised. However, it should be noted that both sides were eminently incapable in addressing the issue of secession. The delusion that have been sweetening our pots leading up to these talks has once again disappointed the Somaliland citizens. The absence of Somaliland secession agenda again on the table is nothing more than a music to our skeptical ears. The avoidance of this agenda is particularly remarkable because of its relevance to the unity of Somalia and Secession of Somaliland. One might think both sides are not taking the most pressing agenda seriously.

Beyond the pictorially staged and carefully choreographed settings, If you closely looked at the nine precision points agreed upon there was no new game changing development that has really been introduced. Except the acknowledgement of the atrocities committed by the late regime of Siyad Barre, nothing new was introduced on the table. Sure some may say this was not a small feat, but still it is only one issues among many contentions. The other main point that deserves a mention is the issue of air travel control. Both sides agreed to form a four member party (two from each party) that will prepare the term of reference of the air travel control board. I’m pleased that this was added since last time Somalia was not able to live up to its previous agreements of the air control. Of course, hardly is Somalia nor Somaliland able to control their air space. Except in dividing equally the revenues collected I don’t see the big significance.

It is utmost important that Somaliland takes note at the pace of the talks. My caution today concerns the point of timing! We all agree diplomacy takes time, lots of time. But unfortunately the snail pace of these negotiations is unsurprisingly in favor of Federal government of Somalia. The biggest weapon in their arsenal is TIME. And, sad to say, most indication suggest that Somalia has nothing to lose in delaying to address the issue of secession, since they are legitimately recognized as a government hence they have no business in limbo. One might even suspect they are just buying time to carve out a sphere of influence on Somaliland once they get to sort out their ever spiraling government. A time might come when Somalia would be able to move vigorously diplomatically and gain a more leverage over Somaliland. This said, Somaliland should explicitly demand that the next round of talks address the elephant in the room. No more should Somaliland allow Somalia to treat the issue of secession as unwelcome burden! Ultimately, moreover, if there is no assurance that exists in addressing this issue, Somaliland should not reignite any more talks. Since the agendas have to be set prior to meeting now, Somaliland shouldn’t reflexively assume they are on the same page with their counterparts.

Crucially Somaliland citizens must not be allowed to perceive that the outcome of these talks without secession agenda on the table is an inch closer to achieving their noble goal of secession. Somaliland authority should express concern over the inability to convince Somalia to start real negotiation. In the coming months, instead of recycling politicians in the current administration the task should be to assemble a different group including Somaliland willing scholars this time. The current foreign affairs minister of Somaliland Mr.Mohamed Bihi Yonis is a highly regarded diplomat with ability to shape Somaliland foreign policy compared to his predecessor! He seems to be a man of unsurpassed integrity and intelligence. Even though diplomats see the world differently and with different priorities I have faith in Somaliland foreign affairs minister!

In all fairness, diplomacy calls for listening, respecting and understanding. For that we should praise both sides for their temperament. In the realm of diplomatic possibilities there is of course nothing impossible so let’s hope both sides get the courage to move on forward!

 By NomadPress


  1. An obituary mixes sweet with sour, with less emphasis on the sour. The dead deserve charity. A doctor’s diagnosis is the opposite. If you cannot identify what has gone wrong, you will never discover how to set it right. Somaliland deserves a doctorate, not a useless debate and discussion. Waleweyn cannot understand this.

  2. Kuluc, it deserves cos Hirsi led us to incredible progress: nuclear power plant.! and more. but why are blaming Walawayn who in no way affects us.

  3. Somaliland-Republic & Somalia-Italia-Federation are mutually Dissolving their 1960 UNION.

    1. Since the Union was intended for the formation of a Pan-Somali-State including Somaliland, Djibouti, NFD(Kenya), Kilil5(Ethiopia) & Somalia-Italia.
    2. Since Somalia-Italia-Federation has accepted invasion and occupation by forces from Djibouti, Kenya and Ethiopia it is logical to conclude that Somalia-Italia is no longer in pursuit of the 1960-Union objective.
    3. Since the political and socioeconomic trajectories of Somaliland-Republic and Somalia-Italia-federation have diverge the Re-Union is no longer beneficial to either states.
    4. Since the original 1960-Union was never ratified there is no legal binding contract to force the two states together.
    5. Since Somaliland-Republic conducted an internationally observed free and fair Referendum following the 1991 collapse of the union where the overwhelming majority(97%) Voted for Re-Independence.
    6. Since the people of the 5-regions that were intended for the pan-Somali-state no longer wish to form the Union the idea of Unionism can be concluded to have become outdated.

    As such the case here is not one of secession but is of DISSOLUTION of the 1960-Pan-Somali-Union until such time that there is a change on the political reality of the 5-Somali states that aspired to the Union. Unions are not forced or bought and it is their respective people that promote and create it for mutual benefit.